Graham Hudgings, the founder and inspiration for our work, wrote to West Chester Borough Council on August 20, 2013, to ask them to protect residents against truck-disseminated insecticides. It is preceded by a note to then Mayor (now State Representative) Carolyn Comitta, who has always been very supportive of our efforts.
Hi Carolyn. I am writing to see if you would be willing to read the email below at the borough council meeting under agenda item #4, “Comments, suggestions, petitions etc… from residents in attendance regarding items not on the agenda.” I am not able to attend tonight due to a prior commitment. If so, I will print out copies of the ordinance mentioned in the email and drop them off to you to distribute at the meeting. Thank you. –Graham
Dear Borough Council,
My name is Graham Hudgings and I live in the borough of West Chester on West Union Street. I am on the PA state pesticide hypersensitivty registry. Last year my neighborhood was fogged with the pesticide Permanone by the Chester County Health Department. Prior to the spraying, I was in contact with the Chester County Health Department to see if my house or block could be exempted, as is a common practice in other communities. I was told no.
Since the application I have been experiencing a variety of health symptoms, which disappear when I leave the treated area and return upon my returning to the treated area. I contacted the NPIC (National Pesticide Information Center) and they indicated that the reaction is most likely attributable to piperonyl butoxide, a catalyst chemical ingredient in Permanone which has been shown to linger for years after application. It is noteworthy that there have been no safety studies conducted on pesticides with catalyst agents and that their use has been banned in many communities, including New York.
I did some research on mosquito spraying and the chemicals used and found that Washington DC, Nashville TN, Ft. Worth TX, Boulder Colorado, Chapel Hill NC and hundreds of other communities around the country have either banned spraying for mosquitoes or never practiced it in the first place since it has been shown to be ineffective at controlling either the mosquito population or the West Nile Virus, has numerous environmental consequences, and is costly.
I have urged the Chester County Health department to halt the practice until a thorough study of the implications for the health of our community can be conducted, to no avail. And so, I am writing to you to see what can be done about the matter. I have provided a copy of an ordinance from the town of Lyndhurst, Ohio, outlining their rationale for banning spraying. It does a very good job of explaining the issues.
Individuals concerned about mosquitoes can take action to reduce their exposure by applying insect repellent, wearing long sleeves, and eliminating standing water on their properties. No amount of spraying will eliminate mosquitoes.
The indiscriminate spraying of chemicals on entire neighborhoods against the wishes of many residents, a practice which studies have shown is not helpful at reducing either the mosquito population or controlling the spread of the virus, is dangerous and unwarranted.
The use of larvacides in mosquito breeding areas and community education have been shown to be safe and effective methods of controlling mosquito populations.
Thank you to Mayor Comitta for delivering this message and to the Council for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely, Graham Hudgings